Milwaukee has long been synonymous with beer. The city was once home to four of the largest breweries in the world (Miller, Pabst, Schlitz, and Blatz), and it was the top beer producing city worldwide for many years. This brewing city is also home to a number of highly-rated coin shops serving the city’s coin collectors and gold investors.
For sales tax information related to precious metals sales in Wisconsin, please refer to our analysis located here.
Here are some of the top coin dealers in Milwaukee:
Paragon Numismatics, founded in 1987 by expert numismatist Andrew Kimmel, a member of the Professional Numismatists Guild and American Numismatic Association, specializes in rare U.S. coins. Paragon takes a special interest in rainbow toned silver dollars. This coin shop is renowned for their inventory of high quality rarities and uncommon date coins, with a focus on eye appeal. Paragon buys coins and bullion, from single rare coins to entire collections. They also buy gold and silver jewelry, flatware, and scrap. Paragon Numismatics provides appraisals, as well as PCGS and NGC grading submission services.
1425 W Mequon Road, Suite E
Mequon, WI 53092
Oak Creek Currency & Coin specializes in numismatic collectibles, particularly U.S. coins and paper currency. Their inventory includes a wide array of coins, from beginner coins to high-grade rare coins, and from early U.S. coinage to modern proof sets. They also buy coins, jewelry, and scrap silver and gold, and offer a smaller selection of gold and silver bullion products.
616 East Ryan Road
Oak Creek, WI 53154
International Gold and Silver pays cash for all forms of gold and silver. They deal in jewelry, flatware, and precious metal scrap. They also buy coins, with a focus on gold and silver coins. International Gold and Silver also deals in commemorative coins, proof and mint sets, rare coins, and paper currency. They have been in the same Milwaukee location for more than three decades.
6113 W Bluemound Rd
Milwaukee, WI 53213
This unique Milwaukee shop specializes both in quiltmaking and in coin collecting, combining the owners’ favorite hobbies under one roof. They buy and sell coins and bullion and provide appraisals. Coins & Quilts has been involved in numismatics since 1991, and is a member of the American Numismatic Association. They specialize in U.S. coins, with a wide offering of higher quality pennies through dollars, as well as proof coins and mint sets.
11037 West Oklahoma Avenue
West Allis, WI 53227
Silver Spring Coin of Cedarburg has served Milwaukee area coin collectors for more than three decades. They buy all forms of gold and silver, including jewelry and scrap. They also offer estate liquidations, free appraisals, and a coin finding service. The selection offered by Silver Spring Coin includes rare U.S. coins, silver dollars, proof and mint sets, Confederate currency, foreign gold coins, and much more.
N56 W6351 Center Street
Cedarburg, WI 53012
Thank you for reading our guide to gold and silver buying in Milwaukee, WI. If you know of any other coin or bullion shops in Milwaukee, please contact us so we can update our directory.