shopper approved

    Buying Gold and Silver in Madison, Wisconsin

    sell to jm bullion

    Madison, the capital of Wisconsin, is named for founding father James Madison. Many of the city’s original streets bear the names of the signers of the U.S. Constitution. Madison is also home to the large University of Wisconsin-Madison campus, giving the city a reputation as one of the top college sports towns in the nation. Madison is also home to a number of well-regarded coin shops.

    Bullion Sales Tax in Madison, WI

    For sales tax information related to precious metals sales in Wisconsin, please refer to our analysis located here.

    Local Gold & Silver Coin Shops in Madison, WI

    Here are some of Madison’s top coin dealers:

    Jim’s Coins and Stamps

    Jim’s Coins and Stamps buys, sells, and appraises all coins and stamps. They specialize in U.S. coins, mint errors, and gold and silver bullion. Jim’s Coins is a member of the American Numismatic Association. They have an extensive selection available, whether you are searching for a single rare coin or investing $10,000 in gold bars.

    Their inventory includes unique error coins, state quarters, high-grade silver dollars, American Eagle and Canadian Maple Leaf bullion coins, and rare pre-1933 U.S. gold coins. Jim’s Coins also carries coin collecting supplies and offers want list fulfillment services. They also purchase all U.S. and foreign coins and currency, as well as all forms of gold and silver, and offer appraisals.

    (608) 233-2118
    726 N Midvale Blvd
    Madison, WI 53703

    Capital City Coins & Jewelry

    Capital City Coins & Jewelry calls itself “Madison’s Most Unique Coin & Jewelry Store.” This family-owned and operated shop offers a beautiful array of estate jewelry and coins. They also offer custom jewelry designs, jewelry repair, appraisal services, and create unique jewelry pieces using coins.

    Capital City Coins specializes in gold and silver coinage, such as pre-1933 gold coins and pre-1965 silver coins. They also carry U.S. paper currency, rare coins, and proof and mint sets. Their gold and silver bullion selection includes popular coins like the American Eagle, as well as privately-minted bars and rounds.

    Phone: (608) 221-0140
    6025 Monona Dr.
    Madison, WI 53716

    Collectors Choice Coins by Forever Yours Jewelry

    Collectors Choice Coins is a division of Forever Yours Jewelry – a small family owned and operated jeweler – focusing on rare and collectible coins. The owner, John Krueger, is known for his numismatic expertise and eagerness to share this knowledge with new and experienced collectors alike.

    Collectors Choice Coins offers a varied selection of U.S. coins, gold and silver coins from around the world, and coin collecting supplies. Established in 1988, Collector’s Choice Coins has served Madison coin collectors for more than 26 years. They also buy and appraise coins, whether a single coin or a full collection.

    (608) 834-4100
    211 E. Main Street
    Sun Prairie, WI 53590

    Rick’s Olde Gold of Madison

    Rick’s Olde Gold has bought and sold coins, jewelry, and other precious metals for more than two decades. They deal in old, rare coins, gold bullion coins, and an eclectic array of other collectibles.

    This unique neighborhood gold and jewelry store is actively buying from individual collectors, so their selection changes daily. Owned and operated by Madison native Ricardo Paoli, Rick’s Olde Gold offers gold, silver, platinum, and palladium bullion, estate jewelry, antique musical instruments, flatware, and much more.

    1314 Williamson Street
    Madison, WI 53703
    (608) 257-7280

    Thank you for reading our guide to gold and silver buying in Madison, WI. If you know of any other coin or bullion shops in Madison, please contact us so we can update our directory.