Columbus is the capitol and largest city of Ohio. It is estimated that more than half of the U.S. population lives within 500 miles of this city. This means a huge audience of potential customers for Columbus coin dealers. Whether you are searching for rare coins or precious metal bullion, there are a number of highly regarded Columbus coin shops to serve your needs.

Bullion Sales Taxes in Columbus, OH

For sales tax information related to precious metals sales in Ohio, please refer to our analysis located here.

Local Gold and Silver Dealers in Columbus, OH

Below is a list of some of the top precious metals and coin dealers in Columbus, Ohio.

Allen’s Coin Shop

Allen’s, founded in 1960, is among the Columbus area’s oldest coin shops. Their selection includes U.S. and world coins and currency, error coins, and coin jewelry. They also offer an expansive array of 1 oz silver rounds and bars, with a special focus on rounds with unique thematic designs. Their other products include proof and mint sets, collectible stamps, and coin collecting supplies. Many of their products can also be purchased online.

(614) 882-3937
399 S State St
Westerville, OH 43081

American Coin & Collectibles

American Coin & Collectibles is a small shop located in Columbus that buys and sells coins of all types. They have been in the coin business for over 37 years. Their inventory features bullion coins, as well as pre-1933 gold and pre-1965 silver. They also specialize in collectibles of all types and have an ever-changing selection of items to choose from.

(614) 231-1008
3501 E Livingston Ave
Columbus, OH 43227

Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry

Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry is a Columbus precious metal dealer buying and selling all forms of precious metals. They have three Ohio locations to serve collectors and investors. They sell gold, silver, and platinum bullion, PCGS and NGC certified coins, rare coins, and paper currency. This family-owned business deals in Silver American Eagles, 40% and 90% silver U.S. coinage, pre-1933 U.S. gold coins, Austrian Gold Philharmonics, Credit Suisse platinum bullion bars, and more. They also sell on eBay and through their website.

(614) 846-4653
190 Graceland Blvd
Columbus, OH 43214

Grove City Coins and Currency

Grove City Coins and Currency buys all forms of gold, silver, platinum, and palladium, including coins, bullion, jewelry, and scrap. They also sell collectible U.S. coins, precious metals, and paper currency. The Grove City inventory includes numismatic collectibles as well as bullion, drawing a mix of coin collectors and precious metal investors. They are known for reasonable prices, whether buying or selling, matched with honest, quality customer service.

(614) 946-3846
2655 Columbus St
Grove City, OH 43123

Old Hilliard Coin

Old Hilliard Coin specializes in both U.S. numismatic collectibles and precious metal bullion. This shop was founded with investors in mind, whether you are interested in bullion or graded coins. Their coin selection focuses on collectible U.S. coins, including cents, dimes, silver dollars, and pre-1933 U.S. gold coinage. Old Hilliard offers a monthly Coin Club purchasing plan designed for those investing in bullion or graded coins on a regular basis. In addition to their storefront, Old Hilliard Coin also offers coins for sale through their online store and on eBay.

(614) 334-2722
5275 Norwich Street
Hilliard, OH 43026

Gemco Coins

Gemco Coins was founded in 1988 to serve the needs of Columbus area coin collectors and precious metal investors. Since then, it has expanded into a pawn shop with a wider focus, though they are still well-known for their expansive inventory of coins. This PCGS authorized dealer’s showroom is filled with collectible coins, paper currency, coin collecting supplies, and jewelry. Specializing in U.S. coins, Gemco carries a wide selection of historic to modern coins, including cents, silver dollars, and certified coins. They also buy gold and silver coins and jewelry, whether a single coin or a full collection.

(614) 878-2646
5311 W. Broad St
Columbus, OH 43228

Arlington Coin & Watchworks

Arlington Coin & Watchworks is a coin and watch dealer. They service and repair watches and replace watch batteries, and also buy and sell rare coins. A member of the American Numismatic Association, Arlington Coin offers historic U.S. and foreign coins, as well as gold and silver coins.

(614) 488-4290
2094 Tremont Ctr
Columbus, OH 43221

Thank you for viewing our directory of gold and silver coin dealers in Columbus, OH. If you know of any other local coin shops in the Columbus area, please contact us so we can update our directory.