shopper approved

    1926 Buffalo Nickel

    Since the days following the Civil War, the US Mint has produced 5-cent pieces known as Nickels. Though many different types of Nickels have been produced over the years, few are more popular than the Buffalo Nickel. This particular coin was produced throughout the early 20th century and is, nowadays, extremely popular in the eyes of collectors.

    The thing about collecting Buffalo Nickels, however, is the fact that so few have survived the years in excellent condition. Being that collectors only want to add pristine coins to their collection, it comes as no surprise that collectors are willing to pay top-dollar for a 1926 Buffalo Nickel in superb condition.

    Grading the 1926 Buffalo Nickel

    Because most Buffalo Nickels from 1926 saw many years in circulation, they are often in poor condition. This is why collectors immediately assess the condition of the coin. There are many different things that could have caused damage to these coins throughout the years, and even the smallest blemishes make a huge difference in the eyes of people who collect these coins.

    When it comes to judging the condition of a coin, this is a process known as grading. Normally, grading is something that is done by a company that employs coin experts. Unfortunately, not everyone has the time and money to spend sending their coins away for grading, so you can use the specifications below to determine the characteristics attached to certain grades.

    Uncirculated: A coin that receives this grade is one that never spent any time being circulated. These coins, though being nearly 100 years old, are in excellent condition and appear as though they were minted recently. Even some of the mint’s original luster will have been preserved, giving the coin a bit of a shine.

    Extremely Fine: A coin that is graded to be Extremely Fine is one that saw only a very limited amount of time in circulation. These coins will appear to be in mostly pristine condition and will show only light wear. Unfortunately, even the limited amount of circulation these coins went through was enough to diminish the coin’s shine.

    Fine: Coins that are graded to be Fine are those that were circulated for a decent amount of time. These coins will show some signs of wear, particularly near the Indian’s cheekbone and around the front legs of the buffalo. Because of the exchanging of hands, the faces of the coin will have been smoothed a bit.

    Good: This is the grade given to coins that are in extremely poor condition. While the poor condition is definitely a drawback for collectors, it makes sense as these coins were used on a daily basis and incurred a lot of damage during that time. Even though they are pretty well beaten up, collectors are still constantly eager to get their hands on these coins.

    Pricing the 1926 Buffalo Nickel

    When it comes to giving the Buffalo Nickel a price, you can look most closely at the condition the coin is in. Collectors will naturally pay more money for coins in better condition. In addition to the overall condition of the coin, collectors put a lot into the type of coin it is. Seeing as three different versions of the coin were minted most years also plays into the price of the coin. The chart below can give you a good idea as to what you can expect to pay for a Buffalo Nickel of a certain grade.

    1926 Buffalo Nickel

    1926 $1.25 $2.50 $10 $20
    1926 D $10 $28 $185 $300
    1926 S $22 $100 $900 $2650
    Source: Red Book

    All Market Updates are provided as a third party analysis and do not necessarily reflect the explicit views of JM Bullion Inc. and should not be construed as financial advice.