shopper approved

    Buying Gold and Silver in Indiana

    sell to jm bullion

    The Midwestern state of Indiana is the smallest state west of the Appalachian mountains. Its capital and largest city is Indianapolis.

    Local Gold and Silver Dealers in IN

    If you are looking for coin shops in specific cities located in the state of Indiana be sure to check out our other local directory pages:

    Below is a list of local precious metals dealers in Indiana, including directions to each local shop.

    Lost Dutchman Rare Coins

    The premier Indianapolis coin dealer, Lost Dutchman, was founded in 1985. This family business is an authorized PCGS and NGC dealer, and offers appraisals and investment consultations. They buy, sell, and consign coins, and offer numismatic photography services.

    Lost Dutchman specializes in rare and historic US and foreign coins, and a selection of their rare coins is available on eBay. Their Facebook page offers frequent inventory and market news updates to keep prospective and current customers up to date on product offerings and spot price movements.

    4983 North Franklin Road
    Indianapolis, IN 46226
    (317) 545-7650

    Mr. Wimp’s Coins

    A Fort Wayne institution since 1962, Mr. Wimp’s is known for a tradition of personal service and fair deals. Mr. Wimp’s strives to offer a unique selection of rare and historic coins, jewelry, and gems.

    Their selection tends to be smaller than that offered by other coin dealers, and does not include an expansive selection of precious metal bullion, but the coins they do offer have been hand-selected for beauty, rarity, and collectibility.

    Some of their most unique items are sold through eBay and directly through their website.

    926 West State Boulevard
    Fort Wayne, IN 46808
    (260) 426-0632

    TLC Coins

    TLC Coin is an Evansville coin dealer buying and selling US and foreign coins, along with gold and silver bullion, coins, and jewelry. They offer NGC and IGC grading services, and have the equipment to test the authenticity of your gold or silver.

    TLC Coins is known for an eclectic selection of coins and other collectibles. They recently moved into a new location, a historic building in downtown Evansville.

    1906 W Franklin St
    Evansville, IN 47712
    (812) 402-2212

    Casper’s Coins

    Casper’s Coins offers both collectible coins and precious metals. They offer a wide selection of gold and silver bullion, and are known for their low premiums, with pricing on gold and silver tied to real-time market quotes. They buy and sell silver dollars, rare gold coins, proof coins, US and foreign currency, and collectible coins. They also purchase scrap gold, silver, and platinum. Many of their products are available for purchase online. Casper’s Coins has locations in South Bend and Goshen.

    214 North Dixie Way
    South Bend, IN 46637
    (574) 272-5554

    Engle’s Coin Shop

    Founded in 1969, Engle’s Coin Shop has made customer satisfaction their top priority. Engle’s offers competitive pricing for coins and bullion, and they buy, sell, and trade rare coins, certified coins, paper currency, jewelry, and precious metal bullion including gold, silver, and platinum.

    Engle’s is an NGC and PCGS authorized dealer, and also provides access to refining and assaying services.

    3520 Founders Rd.
    Indianapolis, IN 46268
    (317) 875-0617

    Local Gold and Silver Mints in Indiana

    Also browse the gold and silver mints local to Indiana. Some of these mints offer retail products, while others are wholesale only.


    SilverTowne, founded in 1949, is among the largest private silver mints in the United States. They produce silver bullion bars in 1, 5, and 10 ounce sizes, each containing .999 fine silver. These are investment-grade bars with a fairly simple design. Some of their five ounce bars feature a donkey and prospector design. SilverTowne’s silver bars are hand-poured, giving them an unusual appearance that is favored by some investors and avoided by others.

    120 E. Union City Pike
    Winchester, IN 47394
    (877) 477-2646

    Thank you for reading our guide to gold and silver buying in Indiana. If you know of any other coin or bullion shops in IN, please contact us so we can update our directory.